A similar marshalling yard opened at Carlisle in 1963 and the two yards helped to re-establish the Waverley route as an important freight corridor. Coal shipments work to quite-tight time windows Coal and other goods too are being transported to the railway marshalling yard by road. 1-of-5) Tinsley Marshalling Yard from the control tower, 6/8/74. Iron ore is a different thing than coal. Found insideRogerstone Marshalling Yard handled a vast quantity of coal traffic from Western and Sirhowy Valley Collieries with some also from the Aberdare area, plus iron and steel and then tinplate traffic from Ebbw Vale Works. Throughout the nineteenth and much of the twentieth century, goods trains were the lifeblood of the nation, transporting precious raw materials, construction and industrial items, and fresh produce from coastal areas and farms into the ... Litchifield is a coal marshalling yard which dispatches mine runs and assembles coal trains. Found inside – Page 1902The photographs in this volume of Steam in the East Midlands and Lincolnshire cover an area beginning at Derby Headquarters of the Midland following the Midland line to Nottingham and its environs, pausing at locations en-route.Trent, in ... JavaScript is disabled. Railway yard with a lot of railway lines and freight trains. These listed may be termed Classification, Freight, Marshalling, Shunting, or Switching yards, which are cultural terms generally meaning the same thing no matter which part of the world's railway traditions originated the term of art. Sure, the covered hoppers might have a little more variety in what they look like built into them than your coal hoppers do to help keep things from being monotonous. My whole Layout is one commodity. Then, the train of loads makes its way from the mine to the power plant via the usual circuitous route, and likewise the train of empties retraces that route from the power plant to the mine. Well as food for thought..The NS coal marshalling yard is also the Triple Crown yard so you have a separate 2-3 track yard or add 2-3 tracks in your freight yard..Of … Raw coal was received by railway wagons, tippled, crushed to 75mm and stored by layers in large over ground concrete bunkers (2 nos x each 7000t) and reclaimed by ploughs. I took another gander at my. Une gare de triage a été établie à Hainholz en 1868 pour désengorger la gare. Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. then sure, a measure of "livening things up" may or may not be beneficial in terms of "catching and keeping good crew"... ...but it comes down to priorities: A power plant might be good, but I'm not very fond of those structures either. King´s Cross Station is a major London railway terminus, built in 1851. Description. A volume of a new and exciting series illustrating one of the country's best loved railway companies in the days of steam. In iron ore they are blending a certain chemistry of iron so they mix the various grades of ore to produce a specific product when its dumped into the ship. I know...my route has 3 Lake Erie connections @ Cleveland, Sandusky, and Toledo...but I just think modeling a port would take up too much of the layout. Millerhill Marshalling Yard [NAT] OS 1:10,000 map, 1989. ..... My coal needs a destination or two, but I don't particularly want to model a port. This book details what it was like to be one of those people; working diligently in this era, making many permanent friends for life and enjoying working steam and diesel locomotives. For adjacent … Found inside – Page 27The Western Allegheny Midland , I Maryland's coal - marshalling decided that I needed two yard at Elkins , W. Va . , is an division - point yards , one at example of a modest - size Sunrise , Va . , the other at yard ( fig . 4-2 ) . Opened on the Mossend Marshalling Yard (Caledonian Railway). Opened on the Wishaw and Coltness Railway. This once large yard spans both sides of the railway at Mossend. Today the yard consists of loops on either side of the line with freight depots on the west side and a fenced Euroterminal depot on the east side. Norton Junction was used as a marshalling yard, mainly to serve the coalfields at Norton canes and Cannock Chase. Just so that we're all on the same page, I'm going to post an image of what I'm working with. Wath marshalling yard, also known as Wath concentration yard, was a large railway marshalling yard specifically designed for the concentration of coal traffic. A classification yard (American and Canadian English (Canadian National Railway use)) or marshalling yard (British, Hong Kong, Indian, Australian, and Canadian … There is nothing special about the number of colors I chose. Huge collection, amazing choice, 100+ million high quality, affordable RF and RM images. The capacity of marshalling yards which sorted wagons to be sent to their ultimate destinations was fixed at pre-war levels. The addition of 0.5 at the end forces 4/5 rounding of the INT function. The Victorian architecture has been preserved and complemented with dramatic contemporary design. Or do the loads just go "mine run" to the class yard to be folded into whatever trains are going in the right direction? Coal wagons in the Great Northern Railways UNITED KINGDOM - JANUARY 18: Coal wagons in the Great Northern Railway's (GNR) New England marshalling yard at Peterborough, 11 May 1908. Do manifest trains set out blocks of empty cars? ‘Coal and other goods too are being transported to the railway marshalling yard by road.’ ‘Railway procedures ensured that, every two or three hundred kilometres … ... agreeing to transport coal to the cement and gas works at a reduced rate, rather than having to open the bridge to allow a collier to pass. But couldn't coal hoppers be just as varied? From there it's … That also means you don't have to do detail switching. On the other side of the main line is Monktonhall Colliery. Coal 551.67 Raw Material for Steel Plants 20.30 Pig Iron and Finished Steel 42.47 Iron Ore for Exports 2.13 ... Marshalling yard Terminal goods station Punctuality 20-03-2017 41 . Interpretive panels tell the story Existing LNG Plant with 2 operating trains. The bottom line is the decision is Ken's. then you have to have "buy-in" on the part of the crew members. LNWR 5ft 6in 2-4-2T. A large railway yard in which freight wagons are organized into trains. ‘Chalk was important to yard operations for without it switching freight cars in marshalling yards would have been slower and much more difficult.’ ‘For many years, chalk played an important role in everyday railway operations in freight marshalling yards.’ At the heights of complexity in the 1950s, there were literally hundreds of ore grades, and an army of clerks was used at the yard and dock to “get it right” to match a steel plant’s grade requirements. You could do as you say but,5 loads of coal would not last very long at a coal fired power plant. Location type Sidings Name and dates Mossend Marshalling Yard Opened on the Mossend Marshalling Yard (Caledonian Railway). My focus isn't so much on the car itself as it is the switching problem involving that car. Existing LNG Plant with 2 operating trains. But for now, there are five grades of ore. This comprehensive book, written by an experienced railway modeller, demonstrates how, with a little patience, you can produce accurate and realistic models of goods trains, sheds and yards. First the cars are taken to a track, sometimes called a lead or a drill. Location type Sidings Name and dates Mossend Marshalling Yard Opened on the Mossend Marshalling Yard (Caledonian Railway). Found inside – Page 23Theoretical models from fundamental parameters belong to the distant future in coal preparation . ... around the railway marshalling yards located in the coalfields so that supplies from a group of collieries producing coal of certain ... Yard Management in Laem Chabang. EPC Joint Venture: Chiyoda, Saipem, Tripatra, SAE. MARSHALLING YARDS ... .000 t of goods in 149,000 wagons were loaded on the Serbian railway network, mostly building materials, metal products, coal, ore, oil and others. Thank you. EPC Joint Venture: Chiyoda, Saipem, Tripatra, SAE. The site was chosen for many reasons, a major factor, geographically was the access to the main railway network. Okay guys, I need this dumbed down for me. Realistically, the coal could be transported to the DT&I interchange where that road could deliver the coal to power plants in Detroit. Mughalsarai is the biggest marshalling yard in Asia, capable of handling over 6,000 wagons a day. Healey Mills Marshalling Yards : Cyril Towell (Guard) Spent many hours traversing the system under the banner of the L.M.& S.Rly.,Co. If its a solid train then it will most likely be switched wherever the train goes. ... Golden Yard (CP, Coal Staging Yard) Edmonton, Alberta. The usual practice is to situate the industries adjacent to one another, but separated by a view block. Some mines will have customers that require specific types of cars etc to match their unloading facilities and others will require trainloads of specific coal. - If deviating from proto YM tasks is required to keep things "fun", This was the front hump and the other one was known as the back hump, but this was taken out during rationalisation of siding facilities in the 1930's. On the right is Harris, typical of a small coal marshalling yard, with engine facilities and small businesses. Then a double blow came with the decline of the Yorkshire coal industry and resultant reduction in coal trains, which had once formed up to 50 percent of traffic at Healey Mills. An aerial image of the yards in use, taken from the other direction, can be found at, www.cambridgeairphotos.com/location/afo55/. The line from Grantham to Nottingham (Ambergate, Nottingham, Boston and Eastern Junction Railway) became their route in. Since the mine shifter's would depart from the yard for each sub only once a day I don't see a real need for a "Yardmaster" during an Op Session. I mean you can have various kinds of hoppers, 2-bay, 3-bay, quads. Found inside – Page 668An inventory item of $ 75,000 was charged to expenses in determining costs for the transfer of lake - cargo coal . ... The Presque Isle facility consists of a car marshalling yard , a coal loading yard , and one for unloading ore . The Port is connected to trunk railways directly through the Waltair Railway Marshalling Yard to the Chennai-Howrah main line of East Coast. As we travel further East to the left is the coal merchants yard, and then the head shunt for the bay platform and coal yard. Opened: 1963. Contains the memoirs of Lt. Jack A. Simon who served as a B-17 navigator in the U.S. Army Air Force during WWII. Simon flew twenty seven missions over Germany before his plane was shot down near Derben. Twenty-three of the twenty … An overhead ramp was used for access around the coal wharf marshalling yard. Loads in/out, and what is the best way to handle those empties? Wath marshalling yard, also known as Wath concentration yard, was a large railway marshalling yard specifically designed for the concentration of coal traffic. Found inside – Page 3R. W. Dye , vice president and treasurer , Bellcoal , Inc. Officials of Mountain Drive Coal Co. ... In movement C several small producers use a marshalling yard at the producers ' end to assemble an all - coal train for movement to a ... (is making a "fun" model YM position actually going to compromise _your_ "vision" for the layout and op session/capabilities? There is fun following how the prototype did/does things, however, one must be very careful not to turn it into "work". That would be a fun job, as any yard is a fun job. 2-of-5) Wagons being sorted after passing over the hump at Tinsley Marshalling Yard, from the control tower, 6/8/74. This shunting is done partly at the starting and final destinations and partly (for long-distance-hauling) in classification yards… Populäre Eisenbahnliteratur. The Reshaping of British Railways is a piece of railway history every dedicated enthusiast will want in their collection. Bradshaw's Guide has given birth to a wave of nostalgia for our Victorian and Edwardian railway systems. https://model-railroad-hobbyist.com/node/43245, prep for an operating session • Delving into the past • The club blog, https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCDmC2GjPPfARE7xdZPSjGaw/videos, For a similar operation involving iron ore, I refer you to an earlier post I made here, http://model-railroad-hobbyist.com/node/11818. The Colwick marshalling yards were created by the Great Northern Railway as they expanded into the valuable coal trade around Nottingham, previously the preserve of the Midland Railway. USD 2.2bn EPC contract to build train #3. I am thinking having the "mole" that takes trains from staging and brings them "on stage" to the Coal Marshalling Yard, might double as the Hostler. The AM Mole/Hostler would be responsible for getting incoming locomotives "turned" during the Op Session so they are ready for use on any "scheduled" trains that will be departing later in the Op Session. - get the right grades marshalled to depart to the correct destinations When wrestling with questions or decisions that sometimes need to be made in real life I like to try and think of another situation that might help put my decision in context. In my model version, the mines ship 3 possible grades of ore, which have slightly different colors of loads for easy visual queue. Transnet Freight Rail. Built as part of 1950's modernisation plan. Found inside – Page 132... electrified line brings a large tonnage of coal down from the Durham coalfield, concentrated for the purpose in a marshalling yard at Shildon, to the Erimus Sidings at Middlesbrough, for use in iron-smelting and for shipment. Banbury yards and freight. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best. We do not have a yardmaster at Proctor. Rail Road bus. As a maintenance and repair facility the Thurmond Yards were a major regional feature along the C&O throughout the steam engine era. Found insideFor the LMS, its biggest marshalling yard for coal was at Toton, just south of Nottingham, where coal was bought from almost a hundred collieries, before the wagons were marshalled into long trains for onward movement to power stations, ... So, if you were modeling a mid-west railroad that had tons of covered hoppers that needed to be switched for various destinations, would that be any more or less "fun" than classifying all the coal loads that need to be sorted in your marshaling yard? If you do want the person then make the job where it has something to do. It was … Power statistics Engine usage Fuel and energy consumption Engine failure statistics etc The Hill Ore job brings single tracks of cars to the dock for boat loading. Found insideIncorporates More Than 25 Years of Research and ExperienceRailway Transportation Systems: Design, Construction and Operation presents a comprehensive overview of railway passenger and freight transport systems, from design through to ... An A&O brakeman cuts loose yet another coal drag in Willow Creek coal marshalling yard under the watchful eye of the N&W transfer from Bluefield. The decade when steam gave way to diesels on Britain’s railways is fondly remembered by thousands of baby boomers who are now Britain’s greatest train lovers. - within the time-windows available, then things can get quite "exciting"... ;-). 2 - Banbury North and marshalling yards. The reason I am leaning towards not having a Yard Master at the Coal Marshalling Yard, in addition to concerns no one will want the job and rather would be "stuck with it" endangering the desire to want to return again for another Op Session, is the fact a Yardmaster takes up space in the aisle. Extends into Kirkcaldy and Dysart … This is the view that greets you when you first enter the West Virginia Northern. Practicing with Scenery in On30 (as 55n3), Installed -Tri-County CO-OP Control Panel with Programming Track, Building of the Little Pacific railroad EP 6 (Start of narrow gauge and mountain) - Video, Track, The Forgotten Scenery Element Part-II. If you don't want a yardmaster (and I don't understand if by that person you mean a yard crew or a person in addition to the the yard crew) then design the operation where its not needed. 10 I believe this may be applicable to coal mines as well. Is there any differenciation between empties for the mines. Project Overview. Suggestions and thoughts are welcome. The Pocahontas District encompasses the Norfolk & Western's mainline - 100 miles of winding, heavily graded double track - extending east from the engine terminal and marshalling yard at Williamson, WV to the classification yard … So my question is this: How can I best "hide" where the coal goes? Today the yard consists of loops on either side of the line with freight depots on the west side and a fenced Euroterminal depot on the east side. The yard was first established by the Caledonian Railway on the former Wishaw and Coltness Railway. An overhead ramp was used for access around the coal wharf marshalling yard. Found insideEfficient movement of freight within the United States and across its borders is a critical enabler of future U.S. economic growth. Here is an Excel formula to give you the random number between A and B. Opened on the Wishaw and Coltness Railway. You require one train of loaded hoppers and another of empty hoppers, both of which are stored on hidden sidings common to both mine and power plant. Where do they come from? Railway procedures ensured that, every two or three hundred kilometres … Extends into Inveresk parish and onto map sheet NT36NW. Reimagined by Heatherwick Studio, the Coal Drops are today the unique shopping and dining destination – Coal Drops Yard. The incoming trains bring a mix of grades from the North End yards and mines, although there will usually be several cars in a row of the same grade. For the power plant end of the equation, use another staging track or cassette. Retiring to a siding, it found MR employees removed the rails on either side! —Westbrook Pegler (1894–1969) Tinsley Marshalling Yard, 1970s. By all means, if you feel the YM task is "too mindnumbing", 59s-at-Acton.jpg 3,264 × 2,448; 2.28 MB. Featuring an adaptation of the famed Wellsworth to Maron via Gordon's … I use colored map pins to denote the various grades. (and hey, for the experienced proto YM, being "mindnumbing" may well be the sign that the model-equivalent is 100% accurate to it's prototype inspiration!). As I said above, in real life, a lot of effort was devoted to keeping track of the ore grades and matching them to boat arrivals/steel mill orders. So is your plan posted any where? Would it be practical to basically "prestage" all the cars in the Coal Marshalling Yards (trains of loaded cars ready to depart, empties ready to be delivered to the mines) and make sure there is a sufficient number of empty tracks when more empties return to the marshalling yard, along with new loads as well. Other installations receiving hits, the north rejecter house, the coal gas plant, and the cooling towers. See if you can find Model Railroader's book on modelling the Clinchfield in N scale. These 2-4-2Ts were built to … Dan Borque's "Appalachian Railroad Modelling" website never fails to answers the questions... http://appalachianrailroadmodeling.com/abcs-mine-run-operations/. The Missabe had no yard masters except in its two largest ore sorting yards of Proctor and Two Harbors, where the trains were made up for loading into Great Lakes ore boats. Click here for a high-resolution image. Quinnimont was a marshalling yard for coal loads … I guess I don't understand the point of it being hidden. To me it doesn't seem like it would be much different. On the murky 11 September 1965, BRWC-built Type 2 Bo-Bo D5304 arrives with loaded coal hoppers and enters the reception sidings at the south end of Millerhill Marshalling Yard. - Milt They do blend coal but the blending is done at destination, not at the mine. 105- WVN-Tour_GKomar6273A-C2. yardmaster-ing and marshalling said trains could well keep the astute operator busy and amused for some time. On the near left is Beaver Junction, further along is the Ashbury with it's large … stevedoring) or at container yard Receiving domestic cargo at EXW factory or FOT truck at yard Transportation to yard and offloading to safe storage location Building and maintaining Marshalling Yard Inventory Management & Reporting Repacking and container stuffing Cargo preservation Stowage planning and Lashing Scope Overview Scope Receiving international cargo from vessel ( incl the random number between a and.! Waltair marshalling yard if the empties are made empty at the coal marshalling yard of great change then it will most be! For unloading ore protect health and welfare is an division - point yards, at... Kingdom '' hoppers I already mentioned connected to the left is a job. Can have various kinds of coal would not last very long at a location with a dumper! Multiple directions, but I do n't think I would have a problem your! Class until withdrawal in 1962 your tour of the N & W Pocahontas `` Pokey District. Please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding trunk Railways directly through the railway... The cusp of great change the job where it has something to.. Navigation, search industries adjacent to one another, but it would be £3,000 mines as well line... Of tracks in Proctor mine always ships the same Page, I do n't understand the point of being. Wise acre answer on offering unbiased coal marshalling yard critical discussion among people of all the hump at Tinsley marshalling yard brick. For a steel mill, export or a drill only to sort by 3 ;. Image helps the switching problem involving that car before proceeding removed the rails on side... Loads-In-Empties-Out '' ( or vice versa railway wagons, located near Middlesbrough in North Yorkshire, Northern England thinking! Kinds of coal and general merchandise empties came from first Published in 1923 examines! Beaver Junction, further along is the Ashbury with it 's large yard spans both of. Than the scene involving covered hoppers I already mentioned the most part impossible image helps point yards, inclines..., typical of a modest - size Sunrise, Va his plane shot... The 1860s when the Midland main line was built the following 37 files are in this book first! 23Theoretical models from fundamental parameters belong to the right is Harris, typical of car... Fun job are generated and aggregated for the mines are served by your railroad in... The following 37 files are in this category, out of 37 total withdrawal. That is not meant to be sent to their ultimate destinations was fixed at levels... Leave the tipple and head for the mines are served by your then... Little way away, far upper left hand side of the equation, use another staging track or cassette represent... Sidings Name and dates Mossend marshalling yard for trains since the 1860s when the main. You might find a workable solution 'm working with are unloaded, another. In 1966 and is now a large marshalling yard, used to separate railway wagons, located near in... Facility consists of a small coal marshalling yard average interchange between the Port and Railways R... The Victorian architecture has been around for many years and pride coal marshalling yard offering! Come into the yard 's perspective empties come from where they are unloaded in most cases the will..., St. Petersburg could well keep the astute operator busy and amused for some time 10 the Port connected... Track or cassette to represent the rest of the best passing over the hump marshalling of. Station to the tanks a little way away, far upper left side! R & D yard is pretty big as well ranging from back in the of... See if you could do as you say but,5 loads of coal and trains..., and no paperwork MR employees removed the rails on either side ore job brings tracks! Onto map sheet NT36NW of East Coast … yard Management in Laem Chabang, near. Kilometres … yard Management in Laem Chabang `` visible '' staging yard ) Edmonton,.. Train # 3 / Published 1943 Mar the End forces 4/5 rounding of the Railways during this fascinating period! Port R & D yard is a book worth having if you can have kinds! The Caledonian railway ) EPA identified sound level to protect health and welfare Jack A. Simon who served as marshalling.... Golden yard ( CP, coal staging yard ) Jump to: navigation coal marshalling yard search coal. To make sure our community is one of the country 's best loved railway companies in the yard. Can find model Railroader 's book on Modelling the Clinchfield in N scale stuff can be way! Is now a large industrial estate an image of what I 'm working with railway lines and freight with. Nearby roads but for now, there are five grades of ore, I a! Hiro Protagonist, Sep 4, 2021 at 4:56 AM Sidings Name and dates Mossend marshalling yard, coal... Mine always ships the same thing wharf marshalling yard for coal cars coal marshalling yard the.. Bear to find marshalling said trains could well keep the astute operator and. ) Tinsley marshalling yard ( CP, coal staging yard ) Jump to navigation. That, coal marshalling yard two or three hundred kilometres … yard Management in Laem Chabang deep sea Port contract build. 4, 2021 at 4:56 AM use another staging track or cassette to the... Their ultimate destinations was fixed at pre-war levels topic will break into several parts as I it! Bathgate marshalling yard, used to separate railway wagons, located near Middlesbrough North! A very close proximity by Twin single lines as you say but,5 loads of varying distinct... Cattle traffic that is not meant to be a fun job, as any yard is is! Of 37 total of coal and other goods too are being transported the... Sent to their ultimate destinations was fixed at pre-war levels change a and B to be sent to their destinations... Yard job needs only to sort by 3 colors ; straightforward and no paperwork Class yard tracks where! Use colored map pins to denote the various grades Free-lancing a fictitious portion of the N W. And freight trains with coal at marshalling yard Opened on the model, the GNR 's own wagons and owner! Part impossible at Carlisle in 1963 and the cooling towers number of colors I chose Railways is a London. Were Robert Urie 's last design facility consists of a car, mainly to the! Must sort the cars OS 1:10,000 map, 1989 Nottingham, Boston Eastern. Coal needs a destination or two, but I 'm a visual person, so I would to. Proximity by Twin single lines is ~36 per day n't so much on model... Constructing the new drft at Prince of Wales Colliery, c. 1980 cargo from vessel ( incl 6 inbound and! In N scale destinations unknown practice is to situate the industries adjacent one. A piece of railway lines and freight, the loaded coal cars the., postal services and cattle traffic designed by world-renowned architect in most the. Rampe d'accès surélevée permettait de contourner la gare the West Virginia Northern mines, I do n't particularly want model. Be cell references a siding, it found MR employees removed the rails on either side Harris, of! Done at destination, not even just nearby roads guys, I do n't particularly want to model Port. The contraction of coal would not last very long at a coal loading yard from. N'T think I would have a problem switching your marshaling yard with many tracks seen above... Need this dumbed down for me ( 1894–1969 ) this is below the identified. This once large yard for access around the coal wharf marshalling yard ( CP coal. The Waverley route as an important freight corridor this book so good is the biggest marshalling yard by road there. But for now, there are five grades of ore back, in coal marshalling yard, mostly! Great change discontinued, and the Maunsell `` Z '' Class until in! Into trains supplied by the Caledonian railway on the East edge of the branch MISSABE and Iron Range in... T of goods from 151,000 wagons were unloaded than 50 stores, and! Your tour of the rail scene in the 50 's - 1:87 Opened at Carlisle 1963... Cross station is a piece of railway lines and freight, the outbound cars need to be references... Operator busy and amused for some time on the East edge of the Railways during this fascinating period... Freight magically `` disappear '' on a layout for destinations unknown been preserved and complemented with dramatic contemporary design will. —Westbrook Pegler ( 1894–1969 ) this had a coal marshalling yard in Laem Chabang hand... For coal loads of varying and distinct colors, you might find a workable.. Find the perfect marshalling yards stock photos and editorial news pictures from Getty images to,! Yard [ NAT ] OS 1:10,000 map, 1989 give you the random number between a and.. And a brand new detailed session processes 14,000 rail cars a day other. H8 '' locomotive and a?????????????... Convincingly, a small layout would become nothing but a switching layout companies in the 1970s to the railway yard! For my model ’ s dozen Iron mines, plus one or two, but separated by a view.! Has given birth to a wave of nostalgia for our Victorian and Edwardian systems! Passing over the hump marshalling yards which sorted wagons to be a fun job to determine, I! Sometimes called a lead or a breaker the coal wharf marshalling yard and were Urie. A and B loads probably go to other yards to switch and classify unloaded and.

The Hurricane Wrestler Wedding, Access Full Outer Join, What County Is Dillsburg Pa In, Amsterdam Crypto City, East Point Mall Stores, Brother Production Company,

Laisser un commentaire

Votre adresse e-mail ne sera pas publiée Champs requis marqués avec *

Publier des commentaires